First pair of heels, going to buy more.
Reviewed in the United States on September 14, 2016
I've never owned high heels before because they're not good for your feet. But a recent promotion necessitated the purchase of a pair of sensible heels. These fit like a dream. I don't wobble. No blisters. My feet don't ache even after hours on my feet. Very classic style with ample toe room.
Good not great for plus size woman
Reviewed in the United States on June 8, 2018
UPDATE 6/16/18So I went to wear them and after putting on pantyhose they are too big! So I went to target and got the heel pads, still too big! So if youâre going to wear nylons I recommend buying a half size down. So I already purchased a 9.5 and will be sending the 10âs back.Iâm trying to break these in at home before I go back to work from maternity leave. I thought they would be super comfy like most reviewers have said, and overall they are. But letâs be real, theyâre still heels! And as a plus size woman, over 200 pounds on that tiny heel will never be the same as sneakers. Iâm really hoping they become like sneakers. At least for my walk to and from the parking lot at work!Every time I purchase something online, I always check the reviews. I count on others to help me choose the best option. My reviews are always my honest opinion and I try to include photos if possible.If my review has helped you in any way, please click the "helpful" button below so that I know! If you have any questions feel free to ask! Thank you!
Comfortable, classic design
Reviewed in the United States on June 10, 2016
I bought these shoes in taupe and in patent black. I originally found them in Dillard's, but they didn't carry my size (or the taupe color) so I turned to Amazon.Comfort: I over-pronate pretty badly (falling arches or flat feet if you prefer those terms), so I have to be pretty careful when it comes to arch support - I need it, but it can't be too much. These are perfect, and cushioned enough that they're still comfortable at the end of the day. I also have a Morton's neuroma in one foot, which these don't aggravate at all (which if you have one you know that this is a rarity with heels). They DO aggravate a big toe injury that I have, but every pair of pumps that I own do that so I can't really blame the shoes...Sizing: Although I wear size 6 in normal walking shoes (and 6.5 in running shoes fore extra toe space), I almost always wear a 5.5 in heels (I suspect it's because I have a narrow heel). With these I need like a 5.25, because they're just a tad too large. I ordered a package of heel grips the same day (I tried the multicolor pack by Nipoo this time, instead of the Pedag that I usually buy, and the Nipoo ones are very comfortable). The heel grips took care of the size issue for me, so now both pairs of shoes fit perfectly for what I need them for.Another note on sizing - the patent black are a touch smaller than the taupe. I'll wear those with nylons as a part of my military uniform though (sole exactly 0.5", heel 3.0", non-contrasting sole, AND comfortable?! Sold!!!), so it's good that they're a tiny bit tighter since my feet will slip more with nylons on. The taupe I'll wear barefoot, so the skin-on-shoe contact will give enough grip to keep them from slipping.All in all, I'm happy with both pairs of shoes and I will probably buy them in red if my size comes back in stock.
comfortable pump for my wide feet and after multiple blisters ...
Reviewed in the United States on February 29, 2016
I have been searching for a cute, comfortable pump for my wide feet and after multiple blisters and sore feet I have finally found a pair. These shoes are so comfortable and cute, I went back and ordered in five different colors!!! Believe me do not pass on this shoe!
Great pair of heels!
Reviewed in the United States on February 1, 2018
Let me preface this review by telling you how much I *hate* heels. Strong passionate hatred for them. However, I work for a bank and black pumps are pretty much a banker's uniform. These are the best pair of heels I've ever owned. I wore them all day for 3 days straight at a conference and my feet never hurt. The cushioning is excellent and my heel does not slip out when I walk. They are high enough to look elegant but not so high that you're teetering. Great purchase, well worth the money.
These are the most comfortable shoes. On a flight attendant and in my ...
Reviewed in the United States on April 19, 2016
These are the most comfortable shoes. On a flight attendant and in my feet some days 8 to 16 hrs on flights from domestic to internationally! I can attest to the fact my feet don't hurt at the end of the day!! I love them!! Will order more of the naturalizer brand.
Beautiful & Comfortable
Reviewed in the United States on August 2, 2017
I'll admit I've wanted to try a pair of these popular pumps for several years, but the ones I'd seen were, IMO, overpriced and/or overrated. They boasted a "long leg look" with the nude color. I figured it was another fashion fad, here today gone tomorrow... I was wrong. So, needing a nice pair of shoes to go with my new summer dresses (ordered from Amazon), I noticed the models wore these same shoes and they looked great. I thought: What the heck, right? Naturalizers at this price? Sure, I'll try them. If I didn't like them, there was that easy return policy. They didn't have my size in Nude so I opted for Taupe, which looked very similar.As soon as I slid my foot into the shoe, I knew I'd made an excellent choice. They fit like a dream. Incredibly comfortable, classy, and they really did make my legs look a bit longer. And the Taupe was just right. Quality, value, beauty, comfort... These are the best pumps I've ever owned.
Poor Quality/Comfortable Heel!
Reviewed in the United States on May 15, 2017
This is my second pair of Naturalizer Michelle heels - I own black and needed a pair of nude heels. These nude heels that I received were terrible quality - the shoes had black marks all over them. I ordered a replacement pair in hopes that this was a fluke. The heels fit as expected and are very comfortable for 3 inch heels. I just hope the replacement pair are of better quality!
Reviewed in Canada on February 4, 2019
I had black naturalizer shoes that were older and I needed to replace them. I thought these would be the same but they were slightly different. they were MORE comfortable, such an amazing cushy insole, the heel was just slightly higher, not noticeably. The leather is great and I just love these shoes! I have the navy ones as well and would definitely order more colours. They are perfect for work and my feet are never sore at the end of the day!
Reviewed in Canada on July 16, 2018
Love this shoe. Classic black heel. Not too high heel and excellent cushioning. Can wear all day without issues. Love the slight platform. Well made. I usually have an issue with heel sliding out (my heels are thin) and the sides by arch always being loose. This fits perfectly to my foot all around. I wear 8 M and this fits excatly as 8 M should. I would recommend you buy your usual size.
Reviewed in Canada on December 10, 2017
I purchased this shoe in a 9W, but, my toes still get squeezed somewhat, even though I have several pairs of shoes from Naturalizer in the exact same size that fit very comfortably. Shoe looks amazing and is very easy to walk in. I would recommend ordering a half-size up.
Reviewed in Canada on April 13, 2018
I ordered wide size but my observation based on buying their other products is that Naturalizer designers do not understand that wide does not mean just a little bit wider sole, but should also give more room for the foot, that the shoe should be more spacious for a full-size foot. Had to use a shoe stretcher to make them W. Otherwise, the quality is very good.
Reviewed in Canada on December 14, 2017
These fit just a little on the snug side but are super comfortable and don't seem to need an additional padded insole. I wore them to a fundraiser and was in them all night as well as walking a block to and from the car and my feet didn't ache or feel sweaty or yucky - which is a huge plus for dress shoes. They are classic heels, a little larger squared so walking over rougher surfaces don't make me feel like i'm going to fall over and lose my heel. They feel like a nice quality and I am happy with the purchase, and would purchase again.
Reviewed in Canada on October 15, 2019
I ordered and returned 2 times before finding the right size.I normally wear 40 but was swimming in the shoe. I returned and ordered 39.5 same.I returned and ordered 39. Still big but not too bad.The only reason why i persisted is because it is a beautiful shoe of good material and the return was free.Order a lize lower than your regular.
Reviewed in Canada on January 8, 2020
While this style of Naturalizer comes with a padded sole and small platform, and is very comfortable, the foot seems to slide down leaving a good quarter of an inch in the heel area. You almost need to get heel pads to fill in the space. Iâm not sure if one size smaller would fix this problem...it may be a shoe design problem.
Reviewed in Canada on August 19, 2019
Lovely comfortable shoes. The colour is a bit lighter than navy more like grey/royal but works great with my wardrobe. The only issue is the shoe liner sticks to my foot and comes out when I take the shoes off. I can live with that too. Good price/fast delivery
Reviewed in Canada on April 3, 2019
I needed to stretch them more than once, but now they seem to fit. But they are rather heavy. Look great, though, and I like my legs while wearing the shoes.
Reviewed in Canada on October 14, 2019
Great purchase. Very comfy and classy at the same time. Exactly like expected. Received it within two days. Ordered on Saturday and received on Monday. I have already purchased a black one and was very happy and satisfied that I have ordered a beige.
Reviewed in Canada on November 8, 2019
This shoe is a bit too long but a pad in the heel fixed that. Other than the fit I am very pleased with this shoe. The leather is good quality and I like the rounded toe box. Much better for the feet.
Reviewed in Canada on September 3, 2019
I've been wearing these almost every day at work since they came in, and i've gone partying in them - they go with anything from workwear to jeans, and they're super comfortable!
Reviewed in Canada on February 19, 2019
I love my new shoes! I have worn Naturalizer for 30 years. I ordered these in Navy, and I am size 4 1/2. These fit just a tad large, not enough to return them, but I did put in a heel pad so they are secure with nylon stockings. Also, the heel felt slippery. As the sole on these grips very well, the heel slipperiness was accentuated. I rubbed the heel bottom with 100 grit sandpaper, and problem solved. Yes, I would buy another pair! These feel and look great with a skirt.
Reviewed in Australia on November 16, 2019
My new heels arrived in less then 2 weeks. The colour, quality and comfort is increadible! 10/10. I can not fault anything.I only wear heels for special ocassions and with minimum walking. I wouldn't wear them for everyday/ 9hrs straigh wear for office work. Also I'm pretty tall (172cms), so wearing them I would be 2m tall ;)
Reviewed in Canada on February 11, 2018
I never wear heels and these are unbelievably comfortable. I had these on for twelve hours at my sons wedding and never had a blister or sore feet. I would recommend these for anyone wanting comfort.
